Models for Success
Spring 2020 | By Robert Stephens
On a Sunday evening, Jack��Stubbs��� phone rings. He��thinks about letting it go to��voicemail until he notices��who is calling: a doctor from Nemours��Children���s Hospital. A small child with��badly impacted teeth needs surgery��right away, but it���s complicated,��possibly life-threatening. The medical��team looks to Stubbs for help.
Stubbs is not a doctor. As the��director of the Prototype Development��and 3D Print Lab (PD3D) at 91勛圖厙, he���s��basically a gadget guy. His demeanor��is as casual as the jeans he wears to��his office at Central Florida Research��Park. Here, Stubbs shows what first��appear to be toys. Behind him, the��constant drone of printers creates a��soothing backdrop of white noise.
���This is the cool stuff,��� Stubbs says.��What you see barely begins to convey��what he means. Over here is a head��small enough to be on an American��Girl doll ��� except it���s more humanlike.��Hey, isn���t that a heart? It���s remarkably��realistic. Oh, and there���s a rib cage with��slime around a kidney.
���That���s a patient-specific replica of a��child���s midsection,��� says Stubbs. ���The��green stuff [represents] the tumor. We��don���t know the child���s name or where��the family lives, but I���m guessing it���s a��girl, about 5 years old.���
In other words, we���re looking at the��closest depiction possible of a body��part of an actual child. We���re also��looking at her cancer.
���A tumor isn���t the nice, tidy lump��you see in pictures. In real life it���s��messy, and it makes the job of a��physician challenging. That���s why��these models are so valuable. We���re��helping doctors save lives,��� Stubb says.
To be able to look at a model of a tumor from all angles, without the restrictions of an image on a computer screen, is completely changing how we are planning complex surgery,��� says Physician Craig Johnson, who is enterprise director of interventional radiology at Nemours Children���s Health System and chair of the department of radiology at Nemours Children���s Hospital in Orlando. (Photo by Nick Leyva ���15)
���A tumor isn���t the nice, tidy lump��you see in pictures. In real life it���s��messy, and it makes the job of a��physician challenging. That���s why��these models are so valuable. We���re��helping doctors save lives.���Jack Stubbs
Physician Craig Johnson chairs��the department of radiology��at Nemours Children���s Health��System. He sees the young lives��that are at stake and talks with the families��trying to cope. He also appreciates the��importance of Stubbs��� contributions.
���The key to advancing medicine and saving��lives is to combine the minds of doctors,��clinicians and engineers,��� says Johnson.�����That���s why Jack���s patient-specific models are��game changers. You have to remind yourself��that each model is an exact replica, down to 0.1��millimeter of what is actually inside that child.���
The phone call Stubbs received on Sunday��helps illustrate the lifesaving process. A doctor��tells him about the patient���s teeth being buried��deep among neurological tissues. Highly��developed MRIs and CT scans are helpful only��to a certain point.
���Can you help us?��� the doctor asks.
This is what enticed Stubbs and Fluvio Lobo,��principal research and development engineer��at PD3D, to leave their lab at the University��of Minnesota and take positions at 91勛圖厙.��Here, they have the opportunity to combine��technology, healthcare and education to do��something incredible ��� one precious life��at a time.
At 91勛圖厙���s PD3D lab in Central Florida��Research Park, Director Jack Stubbs, Principal��Research and Development Engineer Fluvio��Lobo, Director of Generative Design Jim��Inziello and artist Robert Sims ���19 collaborate with Nemours to produce the final 3D-printed surgical planning models. (Photo by Nick Leyva ���15)
A few hours after the phone call, Stubbs�����team receives images of the child���s skull.��Then the magic happens. PD3D director of��generative design Jim Inziello and researcher��Robert Sims ���19 add color-textured surfaces��and features that will allow the doctors to��better visualize the focal points of the surgery.��The information is fed into a Stratasys Polyjet��J750 printer ��� one of the most advanced 3D��printers of its kind, and one of the first to use��FDA-approved software to develop anatomical��models. Soon, a replica of the child���s jaw will��be in Stubbs��� hands. He will deliver it to the��physician, who in turn will use it with a team��of neurologists, reconstructive surgeons and��nurses. They will see the jaw and the buried��teeth and the brain, not in pictures, but in the��closest thing to real life. Then they will practice��the surgery before the surgery.
���It takes out the guesswork, big-time,��� says��Johnson. ���The surgeons can see everything��the way they���ll see it when they open the��actual body rather than on a two-dimensional��flat-panel TV. Sometimes they���ll change their��approach, maybe change an angle to remove a��tumor and also save a kidney rather than taking��it all out.���
It���s something Johnson could barely imagine��when he and a colleague first saw a 3D printer��at Best Buy in 2014 and thought, ���What��if?��� The future seemed to arrive fast when��Nemours partnered with the PD3D lab three��years later. Their first case together provided��the ultimate test.
���We had a teenager whose family had been��told there was no way to treat a tumor that had��grown to the size of a small basketball,��� says��Johnson. ���The tumor was around too many��of his organs, and it had blood vessels around��it. Chemo wasn���t working. He had no more��options.
The Nemours doctors weren���t sure how��helpful a model from the PD3D lab would be.
But they practiced on the model prior to the��surgery and strategized how to specifically and��safely remove the tumor. The boy walked out��of the hospital three days later.
���It���s been two years, and he���s had no��recurrence of the cancer,��� Johnson says.
Pushpak Patel, a radiology technologist, leads 3D printing services at Nemours and works with the hospital���s CT and MRI groups to make the right imaging for the models. (Photo by Nick Leyva ���15)
While Stubbs and Lobo don���t have direct��contact with patients, they do hear the good��news from the doctors. ���Hearing that ��� it��means a lot,��� says Lobo.
Word has started to spread. The 91勛圖厙��team has provided patient-specific models��for hospital teams as far away as Seattle and��San Francisco. Lake Nona Medical City will��present more opportunities as it grows. Stubbs��does admit frustration about moving this��technology out further and faster, even though��the 3D-printed models are being used in 113��hospitals in North America and more than 250��worldwide.
���That isn���t enough. There are thousands of��hospitals around the world,��� he says, holding��a replica of a rib cage. ���This only costs $1,200��to print. We have an opportunity to change��healthcare ��� to make it more affordable��and to save lives.���
���This only costs $1,200��to print. We have an opportunity to change��healthcare ��� to make it more affordable��and to save lives.���Jack Stubbs
Hospitals, despite copious financial reserves,��cannot realistically do what���s being done at��91勛圖厙. It isn���t just a $400,000 3D printer. It���s��literally a village, where expertise in 釵棗鳥梯喝喧梗娶泭莽釵勳梗紳釵梗, mechanical engineering, 莉勳棗鳥梗餃勳釵硃梭泭莽釵勳梗紳釵梗莽, psychology and architecture can make��these tiny heads and hearts come to life.
���Art students are as important as anyone,�����says Lobo. ���They paint each model to look the��way a doctor will see it in surgery. They don���t��make it pretty ��� they make it realistic.���
Stubbs hands over a model of two conjoined��heads, so small they both can be held in one��palm. With this model, two lives could be saved.
���It���s hard to describe how motivating it is��when we hear what we hear on the other side��of this procedure,��� says Johnson, referring to��a child in post-op. ���It���s more than a black and��white image or a piece of plastic. It���s a living��child.���
In the laid-back office at Research Park, a��printer continues to hum. The model of the��child���s impacted teeth should be ready later��this afternoon. Stubbs will deliver it himself to��the surgical team, who will be given the chance��to see the nuances and angles they hadn���t seen��previously. They will operate tomorrow.
���This is as real as it gets,��� says Stubbs. ���How��cool is that?���
MODELS FOR SUCCESS

A clear plastic was used to create��a model of 3-month-old conjoined twins��to allow doctors to clearly see where their��blood vessels are located. Craniopagus��twins, those who share a skull but not a��brain, is a rare phenomenon and separation��surgery requires surgeons to navigate��delicate networks of arteries and veins that��can often be tangled.

This model of an 8-year-old patient’s��severe scoliosis��allowed doctors to show and��explain to the patient and his parents exactly��how the child���s spine was curving. It also��allowed surgeons to determine a surgical plan��that would be almost impossible to visualize��and plan using CT images alone.

The yellow object depicts a tumor��within the abdomen of a 3-year-old patient.��Surgeons used the model to determine how��to remove the mass, which was growing��between his kidneys (shown in dark red)��and his pancreas (teal), while being sure��to not rupture any of his veins (blue) or his��arteries (orangish-red).

To help a 15-year-old patient better understand how a heart��functions��and how his particular condition affects it, doctors at Nemours��Children���s Hospital used this model, which combines colors and labels to��illustrate the patient���s anatomy. For example, the dark blue region in the��front is a pulmonary artery, magenta is the right ventricle and yellow is the��left ventricle.